K⊂Rn is called compact if every sequence (xn)n∈N⊂K has an accumulation point in K, i.e. if there exist a subsequence Λ⊂N and an x0∈K with
xnn→∞,n∈Λx0.
Remark
A set K⊂Rn is called compact if it is bounded and closed.
Example 1.1Struwe 4.2.2
The "closed" interval [0,1] is compact.
The "open" interval (0,1) is not compact.
The proofs are in Struwe’s lecture notes.
Continuity
Definition 1.2(Struwe 4.1.3)
Let Ω⊂Rd,f:Ω→Rn.
f is called continuous at the pointx0∈Ω if x→x0limf(x)=f(x0)=:a exists.
f is called continuously extendable at the pointx0∈Ω∖Ω if x→x0limf(x)=:a exists. (In this case the function f extended by f(x0)=a is continuous at the point x0.)
Definition 1.3(Struwe 4.2.1)
Let f:Ω⊂Rd→Rn. f is called continuous onΩ if f is continuous at every point x0∈Ω.
Definition 1.4(Burger 3.2.1)
Let D⊂R,x0∈D. The function f:D→R is continuous at x0 if for every ε>0 there is a δ>0 such that for all x∈D the implication
∣x−x0∣<δ⟹∣f(x)−f(x0)∣<ε
holds.
Definition 1.5(Burger 3.2.1 (quantifier version of the above))
Let D⊂R,x0∈D. The function f:D→R is continuous at x0 if
∀ε>0,∃δ>0:∣x−x0∣<δ⟹∣f(x)−f(x0)∣<ε,∀x∈D
holds.
Uniform Continuity
Definition 1.6(Struwe 4.7.2)
f:Ω→Rn is called uniformly continuous if
∀ε>0,∃δ(ε)=δ>0,∀x,y∈Ω:∣x−y∣<δ⇒∣f(x)−f(y)∣<ε
Satz 1(Struwe 4.7.3)
Let Ω⊂Rd be bounded, f:Ω→Rn continuous and continuously extendable to Ω. Then f is uniformly continuous.
Satz 2
Let f:Ω→R be continuous and Ω compact. Then f is uniformly continuous.
Remark
You can remember this theorem with the following rule of thumb:
continuity on a compact set⇒uniform continuity.
Example 1.2
Is the function f:[0,∞)→R, f(x)=x+1x2 uniformly continuous?
Show solutionHide solution
We fix an ε>0. We are looking for δ>0 such that for all x,y∈Ω with ∣x−y∣<δ the following holds:
For all x,y∈(−3,2), the triangle inequality gives ∣x+y+4∣≤∣x∣+∣y∣+4≤3+3+4=10. We therefore obtain:
∣f(x)−f(y)∣=∣x+y+4∣∣x−y∣≤10∣x−y∣.
The function is consequently Lipschitz continuous with Lipschitz constant L=10.
Pointwise and Uniform Convergence
Definition 2.1(Struwe 4.8.1)
Let Ω⊂Rd and let f,fk:Ω→Rn,k∈N.
The sequence (fk)k∈Nconverges pointwise to f if
fk(x)k→∞f(x),∀x∈Ω.
The sequence (fk)k∈Nconverges uniformly to f,fkunif.,k→∞f, if
x∈Ωsup∣fk(x)−f(x)∣k→∞0.
Satz 4(Burger 3.7.4)
Let Ω⊂R and let fn:Ω→R be a sequence of functions consisting of functions continuous (in Ω) that converges uniformly (in Ω) to a function f:Ω→R.
Then f is continuous (in Ω).
Satz 5(Struwe 4.8.1 (first variant))
Let fk:Ω⊂Rd→Rn be continuous, k∈N. Further, let fkunif.k→∞f for some f:Ω→Rn. Then f is continuous.
Satz 6(second variant)
Let fn:Ω⊂R→R be a sequence of continuous functions. If fn converges uniformly to f, then f is continuous.
Remark
Usually the negation of the above theorem is used:
If the pointwise limit f of fn is discontinuous, then fn does not converge uniformly to f.
Satz 7(Dini)
Let fn:Ω⊂Rk→Rm be a sequence of continuous functions with pointwise limit f and let Ω be compact. If f is continuous and fn is monotonically increasing, then fn converges uniformly to f.
Remark
A monotonically increasing sequence of continuous functions means a sequence fn(x) for which fn(x)≤fn+1(x) holds for all x∈Ω.
In other words: for an arbitrary but fixed x∈Ω we have fn(x)≤fn+1(x).
RemarkRecipe for uniform convergence
Given: a sequence of continuous functions fn:Ω⊂R→R
Asked: does fn converge uniformly on Ω?
Compute the pointwise limit of fn on Ω (Struwe Def. 4.8.1 (i)), i.e.
f(x)=n→∞limfn(x)for a fixed but arbitrary x∈Ω.
Check fn for uniform convergence.
Direct method:
Compute
x∈Ωsup∣fn(x)−f(x)∣.
For this purpose it is often useful to compute the derivative of ∣fn(x)−f(x)∣ with respect to x and set it equal to zero. Unless you can see the maximum directly, but that only works for "simple" problems.
Compute the limit for n→∞
n→∞limx∈Ωsup∣fn(x)−f(x)∣.
If n→∞limx∈Ωsup∣fn(x)−f(x)∣=0, then fn is uniformly convergent on Ω.
Indirect methods:
f discontinuous ⇒ no uniform convergence.
f continuous, fn(x)≤fn+1(x)∀x∈Ω and Ω compact ⇒ uniform convergence.
Example 2.1
Consider the sequence of continuous functions defined by
fn:R→R,fn(x)=∣x∣+n31.
Does fn converge uniformly on R?
Show solutionHide solution
Pointwise convergence: we fix x∈R and take the limit for n→∞:
n→∞limfn(x)=n→∞lim∣x∣+n31=∣x∣=:f(x)
The sequence of functions therefore converges pointwise to the pointwise limit f(x)=∣x∣.
Uniform convergence: we have to show that n→∞limx∈Rsup∣fn(x)−f(x)∣=0 holds. We first compute the expression x∈Rsup∣fn(x)−f(x)∣: